In sh, is '[' a portable synonym for 'test'?
carl
carl at bdaemon.UUCP
Wed Oct 16 00:57:44 AEST 1985
> >
> > On my 4.2bsd system, the following do the same thing in sh because
> > /bin/[ is a link to /bin/test. ... Is the "[]" form safe to use if you want
> > ....
>
> V7 systems where /bin/[ isn't a link to /bin/test. Any V7 or post-V7 system
> can be made to support "if [ <condition> ]" as equivalent to "if test
> .....
> GUy Harris
I have absolutely no arguments with Guy's message, but would like to point
out that the [ condition ] construct saves only one keystroke at the
expense of readability. E.g.:
if test -f "$1" <= 15 keystrokes + <CR>
vs.
if [ -f "$1" ] <= 14 keystrokes + <CR>
Which is more readable? Note that the spaces around [] are MANDATORY.
Carl Brandauer
More information about the Comp.unix.wizards
mailing list